Cynthia's Hallmark

Photos

Extra large wine glass, who doesn't need this?!

I love picking out a new ornament each year!

Cynthia's has everything you need to put together a custom gift basket with savory dips, mixers and kitchenware.

8918 E 96th St

Fishers, IN 46037

+1 (317) 570-0444

https://stores.hallmark.com

Visit Cynthia's Hallmark in Fishers, IN for a selection of greeting cards, ornaments, and gifts. Cynthia's Hallmark helps you celebrate all of life's special occasions.

Find related places

Department Stores

Shopping

Gift Shops

Reviews

3.09 reviews

Carey D.

11/21/2008

I like the Cynthia's Hallmark stores. If you've ever been to the one out in Greenfield, it is quite an experience when compared to most Hallmark stores because of its massive size. The location...

Read more on Yelp

Lara V.

12/2/2021

Rudest employee named "Judy". I had an online order to pick up in store. Said I was there to pick up an order...she says, "ya and....." "Was it online or what?" In an annoyed bitchy voice. It was...

Read more on Yelp

Megan W.

6/5/2019

I didn't think I would come into a Hallmark store as you can buy greeting cards in grocery stores while shopping but this store has some amazing gifts and knick knacks. I came in to get a variety...

Read more on Yelp

Michelle Q.

12/26/2015

This is the best store to locate those hard to find ornaments. The staff were extremely friendly and helpful with coupons and questions over the phone. Large store lots of selection, plenty of...

Read more on Yelp

Brandi H.

3/25/2020

This is so much more than a regular Hallmark store! There's so many unique gift options that you don't see everywhere. It's like a boutique. Very clean store with so much to look at. Nice, very...

Read more on Yelp

Owner verified

See a problem?